Got Magic or Pokémon cards sitting in boxes, binders, deck cases, closets, or long-forgotten storage bins? Piles of grey shame that you're tired of looking at?
Bring them to Atomic Gaming & Comics and turn your extra cards into something useful. We buy Magic: The Gathering, Pokemon, and Warhammer models at our shops, including bulk cards, rares, mythics, foils, Commander staples, valuable singles, and large collections, boxed sets, loose models, painted and unpainted.
Whether you’re cleaning out old bulk, downsizing a collection, trading into a new deck, or cashing out valuable cards and models, our team can review your cards and models and make you an offer in store credit or cash.
All Cash Payouts For Trades Are Issued The Following Business Day
Walk-ins are welcome. No appointment necessary.
Atomic Gaming & Comics buys Magic: The Gathering and Pokémon cards in a wide range of quantities, from small trade-ins to large collections with thousands of cards.
Bring in your:
If you are not sure whether your cards are worth bringing in, bring them by and we’ll take a look.
Stop by any participating Atomic Gaming & Comics location with the Magic and Pokémon cards you want to sell or trade.
No appointment is required. Walk-ins are welcome.
For smaller trade-ins, our team may be able to review your cards while you’re in the store. Larger collections usually take more time to process.
Our team will sort through your cards and evaluate them based on current demand, condition, market value, and what the store is currently looking to buy.
Cards valued above $1 are usually offered at a percentage of current market value.
Once your cards have been reviewed, we’ll make you an offer.
You can choose:
Store Credit
Great if you want the best value and plan to pick up new cards, sealed product, sleeves, deck boxes, accessories, event entries, comics, games, or hobby supplies.
Cash
Great if you want a direct payout for your cards. Cash trades are paid out the following business day.
Store credit offers are typically higher than cash offers.
Have rares, mythics, foils, serialized cards, showcase treatments, Commander staples, or other valuable Magic and Pokemon cards?
Cards above $1 are evaluated individually and offered at a percentage of current market value. The exact offer depends on factors like:
Some cards move quickly. Some cards are more niche. Our team will review your cards and make the best offer we can based on current demand.
Have boxes of commons, uncommons, draft leftovers, or old cards you don’t want to sort?
We buy bulk Magic and Pokémon cards too.
Bulk is perfect for players who have accumulated years of draft leftovers, collection extras, old deckbuilding piles, or unsorted boxes. Bring in your bulk and our team can let you know what we’re currently accepting and what your collection may be worth.
For best results, remove basic lands, energy, tokens, damaged cards, and non-TCG items before bringing in your bulk. This helps us process your cards faster.
Have a large collection?
We can help with that too.
Large collections usually take 3 to 5 days to process, depending on the size of the collection, how sorted it is, and how many valuable cards need to be reviewed.
If you’re bringing in a large collection, you do not need an appointment, but it can help to call ahead so the store knows what to expect.
You do not need to perfectly organize everything before bringing it in, but a little preparation can help speed up the process.
For valuable cards, we recommend putting them in sleeves, a binder, or a separate box so they can be reviewed more easily.
For bulk, try to remove:
For models, bring them in using a carrier or container so they don't get damaged during transport.
If your collection is already sorted by rarity, set, or value, leave it sorted. That can help our team process it faster.
